Home › Soups › Boiled or Stewed Meats
Boiled or Stewed Meats
Prepare meat for cooking as usual, searing in frying pan if desired brown. Place in large vessel and cover or partly cover with boiling water, boiling with cover fastened tight for 10 or 15 minutes over free flame. Transfer to cooker, using one hot radiator underneath. Cook 2 or 3 hours and season when ready to serve.
This is a method rather than a dish, and it assumes a piece of equipment almost no one owns now: a fireless cooker, an insulated box in which food finishes cooking on stored heat. Everything below follows from that.
- What the "cooker" isA fireless cooker was a lidded, heavily insulated well — packed with felt, mineral wool or hay — into which a boiling pot was sealed to coast to doneness without fuel. The "hot radiator" is a soapstone or cast-iron disc heated on the range until very hot and set under the pot to keep the temperature up.
- The hinge: it must go in boilingThe 10 to 15 minutes over a free flame with the cover fastened tight is not a formality. Most of the heat the dish will get is already in the pot and the radiator when it goes into the box, so the contents must be at a hard boil before transfer.
- Do not open itLifting the lid to check or stir wastes the only heat source. Once sealed, leave it for the full two to three hours.
- A modern equivalentFor the same result, brown the meat, cover with boiling water or stock, and hold it at a bare simmer in a 300F oven in a heavy covered pot for 2 to 3 hours. A slow cooker on low over 6 to 8 hours does the same job with the advantage of a maintained temperature.
- Heat retention and safetyAn insulated box loses heat steadily, and a large joint that stalls below about 140F for hours is a genuine risk with a modern supermarket cut. If you want to try retained-heat cookery, use a well-preheated cooker, a full pot, and check that the meat is still steaming hot at the end; otherwise finish it on the stove or in the oven.
- Season when ready to serveThe instruction may reflect the old belief that salting early toughens boiled meat. Season and taste at the end either way.
- YieldNone is given because the method scales with the vessel. Reckon on 3 to 4 lb of shoulder, shin or brisket serving six, with the cooking liquid strained off as the base of a soup.
Fireless cookery had a genuine vogue in American and European kitchens from roughly the 1900s through the 1920s, and its origins are usually traced to the Norwegian hay box, in which a pot brought to the boil was buried in hay to finish on its own stored heat. The appeal was fuel: coal and gas cost money, a summer range made a kitchen unbearable, and a box that cooked a cheap cut of beef all afternoon while the cook was elsewhere answered both problems. Commercial cookers with soapstone "radiator" discs were sold widely, and the wartime economy campaigns of 1917 and 1918 gave them a second push. Instructions like this one — brief, assuming the reader already owns the apparatus — are a reminder that cookbooks of the period were written for kitchens equipped quite differently from ours, and that the tough, collagen-rich cuts this method suits are exactly the ones the modern slow cooker reclaimed decades later.