Home › Recipes › Pineapple Salad
Pineapple Salad
Mix shredded pineapple with finely-cut celery and broken English walnuts. Serve on lettuce with mayonnaise made without mustard and whitened with whipped cream.
Ф ф do &
A three-ingredient fruit-and-nut salad of the sort that filled American ladies' luncheon menus in the early twentieth century. The stray characters at the end of the text are typesetting debris from the original booklet, not an instruction.
- ProportionsNone are given. Equal volumes of pineapple and celery with about half as much walnut gives a workable balance; roughly 2 cups pineapple, 2 cups celery and 1 cup nuts would serve four to six on lettuce.
- "Shredded pineapple"Pineapple pulled or scraped into shreds rather than cut in neat cubes; at this date the phrase could equally mean the canned shredded pineapple then sold commercially. Canned crushed pineapple will work but must be drained hard, or the mayonnaise slackens and slides off the lettuce.
- CeleryUse the pale inner ribs and cut them fine across the grain, which shortens the strings. Outer ribs are too fibrous for a salad eaten raw with fruit.
- English walnutsSimply the common walnut, as distinguished from the American black walnut, which is far stronger and would overwhelm the pineapple. Break them by hand rather than chopping, as the recipe says; chopped nuts turn to grit in the dressing.
- Mayonnaise without mustardThe hinge of the dish. Mustard is standard in savoury mayonnaise but fights sweet fruit, so the dressing here is oil, egg yolk, lemon juice or vinegar and salt only.
- "Whitened with whipped cream"Fold softly whipped unsweetened cream into the finished mayonnaise, perhaps a third by volume, shortly before serving. It lightens both colour and flavour, and is best made close to the time it is wanted.
- Raw eggHomemade mayonnaise contains uncooked yolk. Use pasteurised eggs if serving anyone pregnant, elderly or immunocompromised, and keep the salad cold.
- AssemblyDress the pineapple, celery and nuts only shortly before serving. Cut pineapple keeps releasing juice and will thin the dressing if the salad stands.
This comes from a recipe booklet of the kind American oil, gelatin and shortening companies distributed in the early 1900s to teach cooks uses for their product; salads were the obvious vehicle, since a good mayonnaise was almost entirely oil. Fruit salads of this kind — pineapple, celery, nuts and a cream-lightened mayonnaise on a lettuce leaf — were a fixture of the luncheon and card-party table, where sweetness in a savoury course was considered refined rather than odd. Canned Hawaiian pineapple had become cheap and reliable by then, which is what put the fruit within reach of ordinary households, and the pairing of pineapple with celery and walnuts echoes the older Waldorf formula of apple, celery and mayonnaise that New York restaurant cooking had made familiar in the 1890s, the nuts being a later addition.