Home › Pastry, Pies and Tarts › Huckleberry Pie
Huckleberry Pie
Carefully wash and drain the berries and sift flour over them until each berry becomes a little white ball. Allow one' scanty cup of sugar to each pie, stir it well into the fruit, and turn the latter into the pie plates. Cover each pie with an upper crust, and bake one hour. Serve cold, with sugar sifted over the top. Flouring the berries in this way, while still a little wet from the washing will make just enough thickening to counteract the excessive amount of juice these berries are capable of giving off. Note: Many good authorities recommend that sugar be added after the pie is baked. The juice is less liable to overflow and the fruit has a fresher taste.
A bare-bones berry pie from an era when every cook was assumed to know her pastry. The technique that matters here is the dry-flour coating on wet fruit, which does the thickening without a starch slurry.
- The hinge: flour the berries wetThe berries must still be damp from washing so the sifted flour clings and coats each one, which is what the recipe means by "a little white ball." Drain them but do not dry them, and toss gently until they look chalky; the recipe says plainly that flouring them wet supplies "just enough thickening" for the juice.
- Quantities the recipe omitsFigure roughly 1 quart (about 4 cups, 20 oz) of berries and 3 to 4 tablespoons of flour per 9-inch pie, with the "scanty cup" of sugar meaning a cup filled just short of level, around 6 oz. Pastry for a double crust is assumed, though the text only mentions the upper one.
- Oven temperatureNo heat is given; ovens of the period carried no thermometers and were judged by experience. In a modern oven a fruit pie of this size is usually started hot, around 425F for the first 20 minutes to set the bottom crust, then dropped to 350F for the remainder. A full hour is not excessive for a wet berry filling.
- Huckleberries and blueberriesTrue huckleberries have larger, grittier seeds and a sharper flavor than cultivated blueberries, and at this date they were still gathered wild rather than farmed. Blueberries substitute one for one; judge the flour by how wet the fruit looks.
- The sugar-after noteThe footnote describes a real practice: berries baked unsweetened throw less juice, since sugar draws liquid out of the fruit. If you follow it, sift the sugar over the hot pie so it dissolves into the surface rather than sitting as grit.
- Venting and overflowNothing here tells you to cut steam vents, but a sealed top crust over a quart of berries will lift or split. Slash the lid and set the plate on a sheet pan; huckleberry juice burned onto an oven floor is a long evening.
- ServingServing cold is not merely a preference. The flour-and-juice filling needs several hours off the heat to set, and a warm slice will run. One 9-inch pie cuts into six.
Huckleberry pie belongs to the American gathering economy rather than the market garden: the fruit resisted cultivation, so it was picked wild in New England, the Appalachians and the Pacific Northwest, sold by the pail in season, and baked soon after picking because it did not keep. By this period the word had already blurred, with "huckleberry" used loosely for blueberries as well. The recipe's real interest is its argument about thickening. Cornstarch and tapioca were both available, but this cook prefers to coat wet berries in flour, an older and more frugal method that predates packaged starches; the appended note, hedged as "many good authorities recommend," shows a household manual doing what such books did well, reporting a live disagreement among cooks instead of pretending to settle it.