Home › The World's Kitchen › Orange Oyster Cocktails
Orange Oyster Cocktails
Neatly wipe three even, medium-sized, red oranges, cut in halves, then scoop out meat, including white skin, without disturbing shells. Place the six half shells on six small oyster plates and arrange finely shaved ice around up to two-thirds the height of shells so as to have them stand firm. Place forty-eight freshly opened bluepoint oysters in a bowl, add six drops Tabasco sauce, six tablespoons tomato catsup, half teaspoon Worcestershire sauce, a teaspoon freshly grated horseradish and two tablespoons Dumas sauce. Mix all well together, evenly divide oysters into the six shells and serve with a teaspoon on each plate.
A cold first course from the era when the oyster cocktail was new enough to still be dressed up. Nothing is cooked; the whole thing depends on the oysters being genuinely fresh and kept genuinely cold.
- YieldSix servings of eight oysters each — a first course, not a plate of hors d'oeuvres to pass around. Scale by the shell: one orange half per person.
- Dumas sauceA period sauce name no longer in use; whether it was a bottled commercial product or a made sauce given elsewhere in the book cannot be settled from this page. Two tablespoons of a good tomato-based chili sauce fills the same slot; the original quantity is small enough that its exact character is not the point.
- BluepointsNamed for Blue Point on Long Island's Great South Bay, and by 1906 used loosely as a trade term for small, mild Atlantic oysters rather than a strict origin. Any small, briny oyster shucked to order works.
- The hinge: temperatureShuck the oysters immediately before mixing and keep bowl, sauce and shells cold throughout. Oysters left sitting in an acidic dressing firm up and go cloudy, and the sauce dulls; mix and serve within minutes.
- Raw shellfishBuy only from a supplier who can show the harvest tags, and skip the dish entirely for anyone pregnant, elderly, immunocompromised or with liver disease — Vibrio risk is real and rises with water temperature.
- Preparing the shellsA grapefruit knife and then a spoon will free the segments and pith without splitting the rind. Save the orange flesh for something else; the recipe wants only the cups, which should be trimmed level at the base if they wobble.
- Shaved iceGenuinely shaved or finely crushed, not cubes — the shells need to be bedded, not balanced. Chill the plates first so the ice does not slump before the plate reaches the table.
- Seasoning balanceSix tablespoons of catsup to six drops of Tabasco reads as mild by current taste, and period catsup was thinner and more vinegary than today's. Mix the sauce separately, taste it, and adjust the heat and horseradish before it meets the oysters.
The International Cook Book (1906) was the work of Alexander Filippini, long a chef at Delmonico's in New York, and this dish shows exactly the kind of restaurant thinking he brought to a household volume: the oyster cocktail was a young American fashion — generally traced to San Francisco saloons in the decades after the Civil War, where oysters were served in a glass with a peppery tomato dressing — and Filippini takes that bar item and gives it a table setting, hollowed citrus in place of a tumbler, shaved ice, an oyster plate, a teaspoon. The bottled seasonings do the real work, and their presence is the period's signature: Tabasco, Worcestershire and catsup were all shelf goods a 1900s cook was expected to own, and recipes of the day leaned on them the way later ones leaned on canned soup. Oysters themselves were still cheap and abundant enough in the Atlantic trade that forty-eight of them counted as a modest opening course.