Home › Fish, Oysters, Etc › To Cook Shad Roe
To Cook Shad Roe
Drop into boiling water for a few minutes, take out, drain, season them with salt and pepper, dredge with flour, and fry a nice brown.
Two lines of instruction covering a delicate ingredient that punishes overcooking. The parboil is the part that matters: it firms the sac so the roe can be floured and fried without bursting.
- The hinge: parboil gently, not at a hard boilBring the water to a bare simmer, slip the roe in for 3 to 5 minutes depending on size, then lift it out. A rolling boil ruptures the membrane and the eggs escape in a cloud.
- Prick the sac firstThe original omits this, but pierce each lobe two or three times with a needle or the tip of a paring knife before it goes into the water. Trapped steam is what makes roe explode in the pan.
- Keep the pairs intactShad roe comes as two joined lobes. Leave them attached through the parboil and separate them only if you want smaller portions for the pan.
- Dry it properlyAfter draining, lay the roe on a towel and blot it. Flour will not adhere to a wet membrane, and any surface water will spit violently in hot fat.
- Frying time and donenessFour to five minutes a side in butter or bacon fat over medium heat is plenty for an average pair. Done roe is grey-pink and firm to the touch at the thick end; pushed further it turns dry and chalky.
- "Dredge with flour"A light coat of plain flour, shaken off, the seasoning going on before the flour as the recipe directs. Nothing heavier — batter smothers the flavour and traps steam against the sac.
- Serving and yieldOne pair serves one generously or two modestly. Bacon, lemon and buttered toast are common accompaniments in the period, though this recipe says nothing about serving.
- SourcingAmerican shad runs are much diminished and several Atlantic states have closed their fisheries, so roe now appears only briefly in spring and often frozen. Frozen roe should be thawed slowly in the refrigerator or the membrane weakens.
Shad roe was a fixture of the American spring table from the colonial period onward, when huge runs of shad came up the Delaware, Hudson, Susquehanna and Connecticut rivers and the fish was cheap enough to be dismissed as poor man's food while its roe was prized. A book of this period needed only two sentences here because the parboil-flour-fry sequence was assumed knowledge in any household near a river or a city fish market between March and May. The terseness is itself period evidence: shad appears repeatedly in books of this era, often with instructions for planking and baking the notoriously fine-boned fish, and the roe was treated as its own separate delicacy. Overfishing and dammed spawning rivers reduced the runs sharply over the twentieth century, which is why a dish once considered commonplace is now a seasonal specialty item.