Home › Pies of All Kinds › Cocoanut Pie
Cocoanut Pie
2 eggs. 1 cup sugar. ½ cup water 1½ teaspoons baking powder 1½ cups Five Roses flour Small lump of butter.
Bake in 2 tins. 1 egg 1ず 31元
The text as printed is defective — a scanning casualty of the original page. What survives is a short, soft pastry or cake batter and the instruction to bake it in two tins; the coconut, the sugar and the filling that gave the pie its name have dropped out, along with the stray characters at the end. Read it as a fragment rather than a working formula.
- What is missingThere is no coconut, no sugar, no milk and no shortening beyond a "small lump of butter" in the surviving lines. A pie of this name in a 1910s Canadian book would normally have a sweetened custard or cornstarch filling with shredded coconut folded through, and often a meringue. Nothing here tells you the proportions.
- Bake in 2 tinsThis phrase, plus baking powder and an egg in a flour batter, points to two thin baked layers rather than a rolled pastry shell — the "pie" may be closer to a two-layer cake split by a coconut filling, a construction found elsewhere in the period. No tin size is given, and none can be recovered from the text.
- Five Roses flourA hard-wheat Canadian all-purpose flour, milled by Lake of the Woods Milling Company and stronger than most modern soft-wheat pastry flours. Ordinary unbleached all-purpose is the nearest current match; pastry flour would give a slacker result than intended.
- No oven temperatureThe original gives none, and none can be inferred from the surviving text. Layers of this type would have been baked in a fairly hot oven, but any figure would be a guess about a recipe whose sugar content is unknown.
- The trailing charactersThe "1ず 31元" at the end is scanning noise, not a measurement. It presumably garbles a figure from the printed page, but what that figure was cannot be recovered.
- If you want to bake itUse a current coconut cream pie or coconut layer recipe. This entry is worth reading as a document, not as a set of instructions.
The Five Roses Cook Book was issued by the Lake of the Woods Milling Company of Montreal and Winnipeg and distributed to purchasers of Five Roses flour — one of the most widely circulated cookbooks in early twentieth-century Canada, and effectively a long advertisement in which every flour measurement names the brand. Its recipes were solicited from home cooks across the country, which explains both the plainness of the writing and the frequent gaps: contributors assumed knowledge their readers shared. Coconut, shipped dried and shredded from the tropics, had become cheap and shelf-stable enough by this period to appear constantly in North American desserts, and "cocoanut" was the standard spelling well into the twentieth century, often said to reflect an older confusion with the cocoa bean.