Home › Desserts-Puddings › Apple Sponge
Apple Sponge
3/4 C sugar. 1 T butter. 1 egg. 3/4 C milk. 1 t baking powder 1½ C flour Salt Slice apples and place in bottom of buttered pan. Cover with sugar and batter. Bake well.
This is a church-supper shorthand recipe: the contributor listed only the dry ingredients and trusted that anyone reading it already knew how a cake batter goes together. Treat the printed lines as a fragment, not a full formula.
- What is missingAs printed there is no fat, no liquid, no egg and no sugar quantity, so the batter cannot be assembled from the text alone. A conventional single-layer batter of this era on 1½ cups flour and 1 teaspoon baking powder runs to about ¼ cup butter, ¾ cup sugar, 1 egg and ½ cup milk.
- Which sugar goes whereThe sugar in the instruction is a separate quantity strewn over the fruit, not the sugar creamed into the batter. Figure ⅓ to ½ cup over the apples, more if they are tart.
- "Bake well"No temperature is given. Around 350F for 40 to 45 minutes suits this quantity. The batter is done when a skewer comes out clean at the centre and the apple juices are bubbling up at the edges.
- PanAn 8-inch square or a 9-inch round pie plate suits this quantity of batter. The apples should cover the bottom in one overlapping layer, roughly 3 medium apples, sliced thin so they cook through in the same time as the cake.
- Apple choiceA firm tart apple holds its slices; softer supermarket varieties collapse into sauce, which is not a failure but changes the dish into something closer to a pudding.
- SaltThe unmeasured "Salt" is most likely a pinch to season; about ¼ teaspoon sifted with the flour would be in keeping.
- ServingServes six to eight. It was probably served warm, possibly with cream or a soft custard.
"Sponge" in nineteenth- and early twentieth-century American household books was often used loosely for a light baked or steamed pudding rather than strictly for an egg-foam cake, and an apple sponge of this type sits near the family of upside-down fruit puddings such as Eve's pudding, in which fruit lines the pan and a leavened batter bakes on top of it. The extreme brevity is itself the historical detail: recipes of this sort were often printed from submitted slips with little editing, and aimed at readers who needed only a reminder of proportions rather than a lesson. Baking powder, which does the lifting here, was widely available as a household leavener by the later nineteenth century, supplementing and largely displacing the earlier saleratus-and-sour-milk method.