Home › Cake Icings and Fillings › Never Fail Frosting
Never Fail Frosting
1 C granulated sugar 2 unbeaten egg whites 3T cold water 1/4 t cream tartar Place over rapidly boiling water and beat with Dover egg beater for exactly three minutes.
Mrs. Earl I. Gruenwald.
Food Products of the Highest Quality
This is the shorter cousin of seven-minute frosting: sugar, raw whites and acid whipped over steam until the sugar dissolves and the foam sets. The whole thing hinges on continuous, vigorous beating from the moment the bowl meets the heat.
- Dover egg beaterA hand-crank rotary beater, standard equipment in 1900 kitchens and often named generically in recipes of the period. A hand-held electric mixer on medium-high does the same work; a whisk will also do it but three minutes of hard beating over steam is real effort.
- "Over rapidly boiling water"Set a metal or glass bowl over a pan of boiling water so the bowl does not touch the water. Direct contact scrambles the whites at the edges before the center warms.
- Three minutes is a minimum, not a ruleThree minutes -- The recipe insists on "exactly three minutes", but that timing assumed the cook's own equipment and heat source. Beat until the frosting holds a firm peak and no sugar grit remains between your fingers; with a thermometer, take it to 160F, which also settles any worry about the whites.
- Cream of tartarThe 1/4 teaspoon stabilizes the foam, and the acid is often credited with inverting some of the sugar so the icing stays glossy rather than grainy. Best not to leave it out.
- MeasurementsC is cup, T tablespoon, t teaspoon. Two large egg whites weigh roughly 60-66 g.
- FlavoringThe recipe gives none. Half a teaspoon of vanilla beaten in after the bowl comes off the heat is the period-appropriate addition.
- Yield and timingThe recipe gives no yield; roughly enough to cover the top and sides of one 8- or 9-inch layer, or the top of a sheet cake. Spread it while warm; it skins over within minutes and cannot be rewarmed.
- WeatherMeringue frostings weep and refuse to set on humid days. Beat a little longer and expect a softer finish rather than adding sugar.
- The stray line"Food Products of the Highest Quality" reads as advertising copy that has drifted in from the page, not as an instruction.
Boiled and steamed meringue icings became widespread in American home baking around the turn of the twentieth century, helped along by cheap granulated sugar, rotary beaters and cream of tartar sold for household use. Names like "never fail" and "seven-minute" advertised the appeal: unlike true boiled icing, which required cooking a syrup to the soft-ball stage and judging it by eye, this method put everything in one bowl over steam and asked only that the cook keep cranking. The Dover Stamping Company's rotary beater was common enough that its name stood in for the tool itself, much as later cooks said Frigidaire for refrigerator. The recipe's form -- a contributor's name, no yield, no flavoring, an advertiser's slogan on the page, and the assumption that anyone reading it already knew what frosting a cake looked like -- is typical of a community or fundraising cookbook.