Home › Canning and Preserving › Oysters on Toast
Oysters on Toast
6 oysters 1/2 tablespoon butter Salt and pepper 1 slice toast Put the oysters and butter in a pan, without any juice, over the fire; bring to a boil and serve on a slice of toast, delicately browned on both sides and slightly buttered.
A single-serving supper dish that hinges entirely on not overcooking the oysters. The original's "bring to a boil" is the one instruction to treat loosely.
- The hinge: barely cook themShucked oysters are done the moment their edges ruffle and they plump — roughly 1 to 2 minutes in the butter over medium heat. Holding them at a boil tightens the muscle and turns them rubbery.
- "Without any juice"Drain the oysters well and reserve the liquor for another use; excess liquid will steam rather than sauté them and thin the butter into a watery pan sauce. They will still release some of their own liquid as they heat.
- QuantitiesHalf a tablespoon of butter for six oysters is spare. A full tablespoon in a small skillet gives you enough fat to spoon over the toast, which is where most of the flavor lands.
- Oyster sizingSix oysters means six shucked meats, not six in the shell — count on medium Eastern-style oysters, roughly half a cup drained. Very large Pacific oysters are better halved before they go in the pan.
- Seasoning orderSalt after cooking. Oysters carry their own salinity, which varies enormously by source, and salting at the start draws out liquor you have just gone to the trouble of draining off.
- Toast"Delicately browned on both sides" means dry and firm rather than dark — a soft slice collapses under the butter. A sturdy white bread or brioche holds up best.
- YieldOne portion, as written. Scale by the slice; cook the oysters in batches rather than crowding a larger pan, or they will steam.
Oysters on toast belongs to a long American run of quick oyster dishes — panned, roasted, scalloped, stewed — that filled the space between breakfast and light supper in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, when Atlantic and Gulf oysters were cheap, abundant and shipped inland by rail in barrels and cans. "Panned oysters," essentially this recipe, appears in period cookbooks with small variations in the amount of butter and whether the toast is buttered. The recipe's terseness is typical of the era's shorter entries, written for cooks who already knew what a cooked oyster looked like and needed only the proportions.