Philathea Cook Book

A church class in Worcester, Massachusetts pooled its recipes in 1922 — and signed every one of them.

HomePuddings › Indian Surprise

Indian Surprise

Four slices of bread buttered. Butter pudding dish and lay the bread in, then beat together, 1/3 cup sugar, 1 egg, 3 tbsp. molasses and 3 cups milk. Pour over buttered bread. Let stand about an hour. Bake in slow oven for about an hour or over. Serve with whipped cream.

— Mrs. Herbert Tarbell

← Baked Indian PuddingRice Pudding →