No. 3689

Stewed Chestnuts

Compote de Marrons

Suppress the shells from two pounds of fresh chestnuts without breaking the meats; soak them for seven or eight hours in cold water with a little citric acid added. Drain and place in a recently tinned saucepan with plenty of water, having a bag containing bran. At the first boil remove the pan to the side of the fire so that the liquid only quivers for two hours, being careful to replace at times a part of the black water by a little clean boiling water, so as to keep the chestnuts as white as possible. When tender but yet whole, drain off a few at a time to peel without getting cold, then put them at once into another saucepan with tepid syrup cooked to twelve degrees and half a stick of split vanilla; use only the whole chestnuts. Cover the saucepan and keep it on one side of the range to have the liquid hot without boiling, and two hours after drain off half the syrup, replacing it by a stronger hot one of thirty degrees; keep the chestnuts in this for one hour on the side of the fire. Drain them again delicately one by one to dress on a compote dish; strain the syrup, reduce it to twenty-eight degrees, and when cold pour it over the chestnuts.

← No. 3688 Stewed Cherries Preserves & Conserves No. 3690 Stewed Oranges and Orange Salads →

For the Modern Kitchen

A candied chestnut compote from Ranhofer's The Epicurean, written for a professional pastry department with a syrup hydrometer on the bench. The whole method exists to keep the nuts pale and unbroken, which is why nothing is ever allowed to boil after the first minute.

The hinge: never let the syrup boilOnce the chestnuts go into syrup, the pan sits at the side of the range so the liquid stays hot but still. A boil breaks the cooked nuts into meal, and there is no recovering them. On a modern hob this means the lowest setting, or a 180F oven, or a warm water bath.
Degrees means Baume, not FahrenheitNineteenth-century confectioners measured syrup density with a Baume hydrometer. As a rough rule, Brix is about 1.8 times the Baume figure: 12 degrees Baume is a light syrup of roughly 22 percent sugar by weight, 28 degrees around 50 percent, 30 degrees around 54. A syrup hydrometer reads the same scale; a refractometer reads Brix and needs converting. Without either, weigh sugar and water rather than guess.
Shelling versus peelingThe recipe removes only the hard outer shell first, then simmers, then strips the bitter inner pellicle while the nuts are still hot. That order is deliberate: the pellicle will not come away clean from a cold or raw chestnut. Score and shell them raw, keep the kernels whole, and peel the skins in small batches straight from the hot liquid.
The bran bag and the citric acidBoth belong to the effort to keep the nuts pale: the recipe itself says the point of changing the water is to keep the chestnuts as white as possible, and the acid soak discourages the flesh from darkening. Neither is essential to a good result, and either can be left out, at some cost to colour.
"Recently tinned saucepan"Ranhofer wanted a lining that would not react with acid and stain the fruit. Copper pans were retinned regularly for exactly this reason. Stainless steel or enamelled cast iron does the same job now; avoid bare aluminium with the citric acid soak.
Timings are realistic, mostlyTwo hours at a quiver is not excessive for whole chestnuts you intend to keep intact, though good fresh nuts may be tender in 45 to 60 minutes. Test one early rather than committing to the clock, since overcooked nuts will collapse in the syrup stage.
Fresh chestnuts onlyThis will not work with vacuum-packed cooked chestnuts, which are already soft, or with dried ones. Two pounds of fresh chestnuts in the shell yields well under two pounds of usable whole kernels, since the recipe uses only the ones that survive intact; reserve the broken ones for puree.
Yield and keepingTwo pounds of chestnuts makes roughly six to eight compote servings. This is a dessert compote, not a sealed preserve: keep it covered in its syrup in the refrigerator and eat it within a week or so.

A Little History

The Epicurean (1894) was Charles Ranhofer's summation of some thirty years as chef at Delmonico's in New York, and it reads throughout like a kitchen manual for a brigade rather than a household book: syrup densities in degrees Baume, retinned copper, pans held at the side of a coal range where the heat could be graded by inches. A compote de marrons is the gentler cousin of marrons glaces, the candied chestnuts long associated with Lyon and the Ardeche, where the sweet chestnut has been a staple crop for centuries; both rely on the same patient progression from weak syrup to strong so the sugar penetrates without the nut shrinking or splitting. The marron of the name is the large single-kernel chestnut selected for confectionery, as distinct from the smaller, divided ordinary chestnut. American cooks reading this in the 1890s still had native chestnuts in abundance; the blight that destroyed those forests arrived in the following decade, and the chestnuts in an American kitchen today are almost all European or Asian in origin.