Home › Meats and Entrees › Oxford John Mutton
Oxford John Mutton
(England.) This is an old way of cold meat cookery. Melt some butter; add some thinly cut slices of under-done mutton, shaped in circles as large as an egg. Season with salt, pepper, onion juice, parsley, thyme, and a blade of mace. Stir it well, and when brown, add 1 cup of good stock or gravy, free from fat, then a spoonful of currant jelly, and a spoonful of flour, blended with as much butter. Stir five minutes more and serve hot.
A reheated-meat dish that lives or dies on restraint: the mutton is already cooked, so it wants warming through in the sauce, not a second cooking. Everything else here is straightforward.
- The hinge: do not cook the meat againThe slices go into hot butter only long enough to take colour, then the liquid follows. Under-done mutton sliced thin will turn grey and stringy if it is allowed to simmer; the five minutes at the end is for the sauce to thicken, not for the meat to stew.
- Mutton and its substitutesTrue mutton (sheep over two years) is uncommon outside halal and specialist butchers. Cold roast leg or shoulder of lamb behaves the same way, though it is milder and sweeter; slice it about 3 mm thick and trim the outer edge of fat.
- "Shaped in circles as large as an egg"Cut discs roughly 5 cm across, with a cutter or a small glass. It is presentation, not technique, and irregular offcuts can go into the pan alongside.
- A blade of maceOne whole flake of the lacy aril from a nutmeg, removed before serving. A pinch of ground mace, or a scrape of nutmeg, gives the same warm note; add it with the stock rather than the butter so it does not scorch.
- Onion juiceThe Victorian trick of grating an onion and using only the liquid, so the sauce stays smooth. Half a small onion grated on a fine grater and squeezed gives about a teaspoon; the recipe itself specifies no quantity.
- Flour blended with as much butterThis is beurre manie: equal parts soft butter and flour worked to a paste, roughly a tablespoon of each for a cup of stock. Whisk it in off the boil in small pieces, then return to a bare simmer to lose the raw flour taste.
- Currant jellyRedcurrant jelly, not blackcurrant, and not a preserve full of fruit. A tablespoon is enough to round out the gravy; more will make the sauce taste of dessert.
- Stock"Good stock or gravy, free from fat" means unsalted or lightly salted lamb or beef stock, skimmed. If you are using a reduced commercial stock, hold back the salt until the jelly and the sauce have come together.
- Yield and servingAbout two servings from the meat off a modest joint end. Serve with mashed or boiled potatoes, or on toast, and put it on the plate immediately — it does not hold.
Cold-meat cookery was a whole genre in nineteenth-century English household books, driven by the Sunday joint and the need to make Monday and Tuesday out of it; Eliza Acton, Mrs Beeton and their successors all carry pages of rechauffés, hashes and mince. "Oxford John" appears in nineteenth-century English cookery writing, and the name is generally traced to the university town rather than to any identifiable John, though no origin story for it is documented. The formula is stable across versions: thin rounds of cooked mutton, sweet herbs and mace, a gravy sharpened with redcurrant jelly and thickened with butter and flour. Its presence in a book of dishes gathered from abroad reflects the period's habit of collecting national specimens — one representative English dish, filed alongside a French entrée and an Italian one.