Home › Pastry and Puddings › Charlotte Russe (Take a box of sparkling)
Charlotte Russe (Take a box of sparkling)
Take a box of sparkling gelatine and pour on it a scant pint and a half of cold water; when it has stood ten minutes add the same quantity of boiling water, and stir until the gelatine is dissolved; stir in half a pound of white sugar; have ready six eggs, well beaten separately, and then together, and when the jelly is cool, but not congealed, beat it into the eggs; whip very lightly three pints of rich cream, flavored with vanilla or almond, or both, and when the eggs and jelly begin to congeal, beat it in as rapidly as possible, and pour the mixture in a bowl lined with lady-fingers or sponge-cake
This is a raw-egg charlotte: six whole eggs are beaten into gelatine that has already cooled, and nothing in the method ever brings the mixture to a temperature that would make it safe. The notes below explain where it fails rather than how to rescue it.
- The eggs are never cookedEqual volumes of boiling and cold water leave the gelatine syrup warm at best, and the recipe directs that the eggs go in only when the jelly is cool, so the eggs never reach a temperature that would cook them. Whole raw eggs, yolks and whites, carry a Salmonella risk that no amount of whipping or chilling addresses. A modern charlotte russe filling is built on a cooked custard base or on pasteurised eggs; use a current recipe.
- A long hold in the danger zoneThe mixture is beaten while it slowly sets, then poured into a lined bowl and left to firm up. Even refrigerated, a sweetened egg-and-cream mass of this size takes hours to chill through the middle, and the recipe as written gives no chilling instruction at all.
- Scale of the thingThree pints of cream plus six eggs plus roughly three pints of jelly makes a very large bowl, which also means the mass chills slowly through the middle.
- "A box of sparkling gelatine"This refers to a packaged granulated gelatine of the later nineteenth century, on the order of half an ounce to an ounce per box; the strength is not stated and cannot be reliably matched to modern powdered gelatine or sheet grades. Any conversion would be a guess.
- Half a pound of white sugarEight ounces, a little over a cup by modern measure. Worth noting only because sugar at this level does nothing to preserve the mixture or inhibit bacteria, contrary to a common assumption about very sweet desserts.
- Flavoring with almondNineteenth-century almond flavoring was frequently bitter-almond essence, which in its unrectified form contains cyanogenic compounds. Commercial almond extract sold today is rectified or synthetic and is not the same product.
The charlotte russe is generally traced to Marie-Antoine Carême, who is said to have renamed an earlier charlotte à la parisienne in honour of a Russian patron, and it reached American cookbooks as a mould lined with ladyfingers or split sponge cake and filled with a set cream. By the later nineteenth century gelatine-and-whipped-cream versions like this one appear alongside the older cooked-custard fillings, packaged granulated gelatine -- sold in labelled boxes, with "sparkling" used as a selling point for clarity -- making a firm set possible without a stove. That convenience is exactly what this recipe leans on: no cooking, no thermometer, no custard to curdle. It is also a record of a period that had no working understanding of egg-borne Salmonella.