Home › Fish, Oysters, Etc › To Fry Silver Fish
To Fry Silver Fish
This is a very delicate fish, and found principally in the south. Dress the fish nicely, roll the body in beaten egg and then in cracker crumbs, and fry in butter.
A three-line recipe that assumes you know how to handle small pan fish. The gaps are the fish itself, the size of the pieces, and the fact that butter alone will scorch before the coating browns.
- What "silver fish" meansThe name appears to have been used loosely for small silvery pan fish rather than one species; silversides and silver perch are among the candidates. Any small, thin-fleshed fish, whole and pan-dressed, behaves the same way here; small whole trout, smelt or fresh sardines are close substitutes.
- "Dress the fish nicely"Scale, gut, trim the fins, and remove the head if you prefer. The recipe says to roll "the body" in egg, so the fish is cooked whole on the bone; they hold together far better unfilleted.
- Cracker crumbsSoda crackers or water biscuits crushed fine, not modern seasoned breadcrumbs. Saltines pounded in a bag give the right coarse, salty crust; panko is too airy and browns unevenly in butter.
- Dry the fish firstThe one step the recipe omits and the one that decides the outcome. Pat the fish thoroughly dry before the egg, or the coating slides off in the pan. A light dusting of seasoned flour before the egg helps it grip.
- Butter will burnWhole butter begins to brown and then smoke in the region of 300-350F, below what a crumb crust needs for a good colour. Use clarified butter, or half butter and half a neutral oil, and hold the pan at medium — the coating wants 3-4 minutes a side for a fish this size.
- SeasoningNothing is called for. Salt the fish itself before coating and add a pinch to the crumbs; otherwise the crust tastes flat.
- DonenessThe flesh should flake from the backbone and read about 145F at the thickest point. Small fish overcook fast — pull them as soon as the fin bones lift free.
- Yield and servingFigure two small fish per person. Lemon and a little of the pan butter suit the dish, though the recipe calls for neither; drain briefly on paper first.
Egg-and-cracker-crumb frying was the standard American treatment for small fish through the nineteenth century, and cracker crumbs rather than bread crumbs mark the recipe as domestic and thrifty — soda crackers were a pantry staple that kept well and crushed to a crumb finer and drier than stale bread. The note that the fish is "found principally in the south" flags the fish as unfamiliar to Northern cooks rather than explaining it. "Silver fish" was never a single fixed species but a market name applied to various small silversided pan fish, which is why the recipe describes handling and not identification — anyone who had the fish knew what it was, and anyone who did not was unlikely to find it at market.