Home › Fish, Oysters, Etc › Turtle or Terrapin Stew
Turtle or Terrapin Stew
Parboil the meat, mince it, and season very highly with cayenne pepper, black pepper, salt, spices, lemon, hard-boiled eggs and champagne. Stew until thoroughly done. Very fine.
This is a period note rather than a workable recipe, and the animal at its centre is no longer available to a home cook. The points below explain what stands in the way.
- The turtle is the problemThe "turtle" of nineteenth-century American cookery was most often the green sea turtle, imported live or as canned meat, though snapping turtle was also used. All sea turtles are now protected under the U.S. Endangered Species Act and listed by CITES; possession, purchase or preparation is prohibited.
- Terrapin is not a substituteThe diamondback terrapin, the luxury version of this dish, was harvested nearly to collapse by the early twentieth century. It is now protected or its take tightly restricted across its Atlantic and Gulf range, and commercial sale is barred in many states. Do not read "or terrapin" as an escape route.
- Snapping turtle is regulated, not openCommon snapping turtle is still taken legally in some jurisdictions, but seasons, licences, size limits and sale restrictions vary state by state, and advisories exist for contaminant levels in the fat and liver. This recipe gives no guidance that would make such a substitution sound.
- No quantities at allThere is no weight of meat, no volume of liquid, no salt measure and no egg count. "Season very highly" and "spices" are placeholders for a cook who already knew the dish; nothing here can be scaled or reproduced.
- No times or temperatures"Parboil" and "stew until thoroughly done" are the only cooking directions. Turtle meat is connective-tissue heavy and was traditionally simmered for hours; the instruction as printed gives a reader no way to judge doneness of an unfamiliar meat.
- Use a current recipeIf you want the flavour profile — cayenne, black pepper, unspecified spices, lemon, hard-boiled egg and champagne — work from a modern recipe built around a legal, farmed protein rather than adapting this one.
Turtle soup and terrapin stew sat at the top of American restaurant menus for most of the nineteenth century, which is why a book like this can dispose of the dish in three lines: the reader was assumed to know it. Green sea turtle came north from the Caribbean and Florida by ship, kept alive in the hold, while diamondback terrapin from the Chesapeake became the greater delicacy, sold by the dozen and graded by size Maryland and Philadelphia cooking both claimed it, and the version enriched with hard-boiled egg yolk, cream or wine is generally traced to those kitchens. Champagne here is a marker of the dish's status rather than a culinary necessity; Madeira and sherry are the fortifications more commonly encountered in printed versions. Demand of exactly this kind emptied the beds and the nesting beaches, and by the interwar years terrapin had priced and fished itself off the menu. "Mock turtle," made from a calf's head, outlived the real thing.