Home › Luncheon Dishes › Sweet Sour Pot Roast
Sweet Sour Pot Roast
Take a piece of chuck or better rump roast, and place in a kettle with a slice of bacon cut small, several carrots and one onion, and sear both sides of the meat. Add 1 pt. water 12 t allspice 12 t paprika 1 pt. vinegar Boil until meat is tender. 1/4 t red pepper 14 t cloves Salt to taste 1 T sugar Remove meat and strain the gravy. Then thicken it with 1 T brown fiour. Return meat to the gravy and keep warm until ready to serve.
Mrs. Graeff.
A German-style sauerbraten reduced to a single-kettle braise, with the souring done in the pot rather than by a multi-day marinade. The ingredient list runs in two columns in the original, so read the amounts as a group rather than in sequence.
- The hinge: equal water and vinegarA full pint of vinegar against a pint of water is aggressive by modern taste, and it is the whole character of the dish. Cider vinegar rather than distilled white gives a rounder result, and the single tablespoon of sugar is there to balance it — taste at the end and add more if the sauce bites.
- Ambiguous spice quantitiesThe allspice, paprika and clove measures are printed in a way that no longer reads clearly. Half a teaspoon each of allspice and paprika and a quarter teaspoon of cloves fit the scale of a roast this size, but the original figures cannot be recovered with certainty.
- Cut and sizeRump is the better choice as the recipe says; chuck works but shreds more. Figure a 3 to 4 lb piece, which serves six to eight, and expect 2½ to 3 hours of gentle cooking.
- "Boil" means simmerAn actual boil will squeeze the meat tough and cloud the gravy. Bring it up, then hold it at a bare tremble, covered, on the stove.
- Brown flourFlour toasted dry in a skillet until the colour of weak coffee. It thickens less than raw flour, so one tablespoon gives a thin, glossy sauce rather than a thick one; use two if you want body. Slake it with a little cold liquid before stirring it in.
- Searing in the kettleGet the bacon fat properly hot and brown the meat before the carrots and onion go soft, or nothing will colour. Lifting the vegetables out during the sear is worth the extra minute.
- ServingTraditionally potato dumplings, spaetzle or boiled potatoes to absorb the sauce. Red cabbage on the side is the usual partner.
Sweet-sour pot roast is sauerbraten adapted to an American church-supper kitchen. Classic sauerbraten marinates the beef in vinegar and spice for two to four days before cooking; here the acid goes straight into the braising liquid, which cuts the timeline to an afternoon at the cost of some depth — a compromise typical of community cookbooks, where recipes were traded between neighbours and trimmed to what a busy household would actually do. The browned flour thickening and the bacon used as the searing fat both point to an older continental technique that survived in these collections long after commercial shortenings and cornstarch were available.