Home › Desserts › Maple Italian Cream
Maple Italian Cream
Add one cup maple sugar to hot custard in Italian Cream before adding gelatine.
This is a variation line, not a standalone recipe: it assumes you have the book's Italian Cream in front of you, a stirred custard set with gelatine and lightened with whipped cream. Everything here concerns the maple substitution and the points where that base custard can go wrong.
- The hinge: add the sugar off the direct heatThe hinge: when the sugar goes in -- Maple sugar goes into the hot custard before the gelatine, as written; the book does not say whether the pan is on or off the heat. Modern practice is to stir it in off the burner, since a stirred egg custard will curdle somewhere around 180F.
- Maple sugar in 1907This most likely means hard cake maple sugar, sold in blocks or moulded rounds, though softer stirred and granulated maple sugars were also on the market. A cup of the granulated product weighs roughly 5-6 oz; grate or chop a cake to about the same weight rather than trying to pack shards into a measure.
- If you substitute syrupPure maple syrup can stand in for the sugar, but published equivalents vary and syrup brings liquid the set was not designed for. Reduce it over heat and let it cool before it meets the custard, or the gelatine will be diluted.
- Cut the base recipe's sugarThe instruction adds a cup of sweetening on top of whatever the original Italian Cream calls for. Reduce the plain sugar in the base by most of that amount or the finished cream is cloying and the maple flavour is buried.
- Gelatine then and nowPeriod granulated gelatine may not match modern powder exactly. One modern envelope, about 1/4 oz or 2 1/4 teaspoons, sets roughly two cups of liquid to a mould-firm cream; soften it in cold water first and stir it into the hot custard until no grains remain.
- Chilling and unmouldingThe book gives no time. Allow at least four hours in a mould, or overnight. Dip the mould in warm water for a few seconds and invert onto a chilled plate.
- YieldThe book gives no yield here. A custard-and-cream base of this kind, if made in a quart mould, would serve six to eight.
Lowney's Cook Book was written by Maria Willett Howard and published in 1907 by the Walter M. Lowney Company, a Boston chocolate manufacturer, and it ran a full dessert chapter alongside the chocolate work. "Italian cream" in American books of this period generally means a gelatine-set custard folded with whipped cream, a near relation of Bavarian cream, and the name was applied loosely rather than pointing to any documented Italian original. The maple version reflects a New England habit of treating maple sugar as an ordinary sweetener rather than a novelty: it arrived in hard cakes from Vermont, New Hampshire and Quebec, and was grated as needed. Terse one-line variations like this one are typical of the book's economy, which assumed a cook working straight through the chapter with the base recipe already read.