Home › Whites of Eggs › Soft Boiled Eggs No. 1
Soft Boiled Eggs No. 1
With a spoon put the eggs in a saucepan of boiling water to cover. Remove to back of stove, or where the water will keep very hot, but not boil. Let the eggs remain in the water for five minutes always covered. Break into warm egg cups and season with salt, pepper, butter and a few drops of vinegar.
This is coddling rather than boiling: the eggs finish in water held just below a simmer, which sets the white gently while leaving the yolk loose. A few details of the original assume a coal range and a smaller egg than you will buy today.
- "Back of the stove"On a wood or coal range this was the cooler zone where a pan would stay hot without bubbling. On a modern hob, bring the water to a full boil, lower the eggs in, then take the pan off the heat entirely and cover it.
- Timing and egg sizeFive minutes suits a room-temperature egg; the recipe gives no egg size. A fridge-cold large or extra-large egg may still be largely liquid at five minutes, so give it longer, or let the eggs sit out for half an hour first.
- Cracking without shatteringLowering the eggs in with a spoon, as directed, is the point of that instruction: dropped eggs crack on the pan bottom. A pin-prick in the broad end also vents the air cell and helps.
- "Break into warm egg cups"The author means turning the egg out of its shell into the cup, not standing the whole egg upright to be topped. Warming the cups matters here, since a soft egg loses heat fast once shelled.
- The vinegarA few drops of cider or white wine vinegar suits shelled soft eggs and reads as sharper than butter alone. Malt vinegar is too assertive for the quantity involved.
- YieldThe recipe specifies no number of eggs; two per person is a usual breakfast serving. The method scales as long as the pan holds enough water to keep its heat when the eggs go in.
- A note on donenessA yolk cooked this way does not reach a temperature that would kill salmonella. That is normal for a soft-boiled egg, but it is worth knowing if you are cooking for someone pregnant, elderly or immune-compromised.
Meatless Cookery belongs to the run of American cookbooks published around the First World War, when meat conservation was a civic campaign and eggs, cheese and pulses were promoted as the protein that would replace it. The technique itself is older than the book and is closer to coddling, a term English cooks used for cooking gently in water short of the boil, though its application specifically to eggs is later. Instructions to move a pan "to the back of the stove" appear frequently in cookbooks of this era and are a reminder that a range had a heat gradient built into it rather than a dial.